Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments walkthrough

Embark on six distinct investigations as the world's greatest detective in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments. This walkthrough provides comprehensive guidance through each case, detailing key clues, deductions, and the crucial moral choices that define the game. Utilize Holmes's extraordinary powers of observation and deduction to unravel complex mysteries, ultimately deciding the fate of those involved.

Table of Contents

1. The Fate of Black Peter: A whaling captain is found harpooned to the wall of his cabin.
2. Riddle on the Rails: A man is found dead in a train compartment, with a strange riddle as the only clue.
3. Blood Bath: A series of murders with occult overtones takes place in Whitechapel.
4. The Abbey Grange Affair: A nobleman is found dead in his manor, with robbery as the apparent motive.
5. The Kew Gardens Drama: The director of Kew Gardens is found dead, with a rare plant stolen from his collection.
6. A Half Moon Walk: The brother of one of Holmes' Baker Street Irregulars is accused of murder.

Case 1: The Fate of Black Peter

This walkthrough will guide you through the first case in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, "The Fate of Black Peter."

I. The Crime Scene

1. Woodman's Lee: Arrive at the crime scene with Lestrade.
2. The Shed: Enter the shed where Peter Carey was found.
3. Examine the Body:
   • Note the harpoon through his chest.
   • Observe the "Black Peter" tattoo on his arm.
   • Check his pockets for a tobacco pouch and a knife.
4. Examine the Scene:
   • Look for signs of a struggle.
   • Inspect the broken chair.
   • Notice the overturned table and scattered objects.
   • Find footprints near the window.
5. Use Sherlock's Senses:
   • Use your imagination to reconstruct the events.
   • Use your senses to detect the smell of fish and alcohol.

II. Gathering Evidence

1. Outside the Shed:
   • Examine the footprints leading to and from the shed.
   • Find a broken bottle near the window.
2. Interview Mrs. Carey:
   • Question her about her husband's habits and any recent visitors.
   • Learn about his past as a whaling captain.
3. Return to the Shed:
   • Examine the ship's logbook.
   • Find a hidden compartment with a coded message.
4. Visit the Whitechapel Butcher:
   • Ask Watson to help you with an experiment involving a harpoon and a pig carcass.
   • Determine the force required to drive a harpoon through a human body.

III. Deduction and Interrogation

1. Use the Deduction Board:
   • Connect the clues you've gathered to form deductions.
   • Consider different scenarios and motives.
2. Identify Potential Suspects:
   • Consider Mrs. Carey, a potential business rival, or someone connected to Carey's past.
3. Interrogate the Suspects:
   • Use your observation skills to detect lies and inconsistencies.
   • Present your evidence and deductions to each suspect.

IV. Moral Choice

1. Make Your Accusation:
   • Based on your deductions, accuse the person you believe is responsible.
2. Choose to Condemn or Absolve:
   • Consider the evidence and the suspect's motives.
   • Decide whether to condemn them to punishment or absolve them of guilt.

V. Possible Outcomes

There are multiple possible outcomes in this case, depending on your deductions and moral choice. You can accuse different suspects and choose to condemn or absolve them, leading to different endings.

Key Clues and Deductions:

• The harpoon is the murder weapon.
• The broken chair and overturned table suggest a struggle.
• The footprints indicate someone fled the scene.
• The ship's logbook and coded message provide insights into Carey's past.
• The experiment at the butcher's shop helps determine the force of the blow.

By carefully examining the crime scene, gathering evidence, and using your deduction skills, you can solve the mystery of Black Peter's death and make a moral choice that will affect the outcome of the case.

Case 2: Riddle on the Rails

This walkthrough will guide you through the second case in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, "Riddle on the Rails."

I. The Crime Scene – The Train Compartment

1. Arrive at the Scene: You and Watson arrive at the train station where a body has been discovered.
2. Enter the Compartment: Examine the locked train compartment.
3. Examine the Body:
   • Note the position of the body and the single gunshot wound to the head.
   • Check for any signs of struggle or forced entry.
   • Examine the victim’s clothing and personal effects. Note the absence of a ticket.
4. Examine the Compartment:
   • Pay attention to the locked door from the inside.
   • Look for any disturbances or signs of tampering.
   • Find the riddle written on a piece of paper. This is a crucial clue.
   • Notice the small hole in the window.
5. Use Sherlock’s Senses:
   • Reconstruct the possible events using your imagination.
   • Focus on the smell of gunpowder and the confined space.

II. Gathering Evidence

1. Examine the Train Tracks: Look for any footprints or signs of someone having walked along the tracks.

2. Interview the Conductor: Question him about the journey, any unusual occurrences, and the locking mechanism of the compartment doors.

3. Examine the Riddle: This is a key part of the investigation. The riddle needs to be deciphered to provide clues about the victim and the circumstances of his death. The riddle is:

   • “I have cities, but no houses; forests, but no trees; and water, but no fish. What am I?”

   The answer is a map. This hints at a location.

4. Visit the Map Shop: Go to a map shop and inquire about any recent purchases of unusual or specific maps. The shopkeeper will provide you with information about a specific map the victim purchased.

5. Check the Victim's Pockets Again: With the knowledge from the map shop, re-examine the victim. You'll find a small piece of a map tucked away. This piece corresponds to a location near a tunnel.

III. Deduction and Interrogation

1. Use the Deduction Board: Connect the clues: the locked compartment, the riddle, the map, the gunshot wound, and the hole in the window.
2. Consider Possible Scenarios: Was it suicide? Was it murder, staged to look like suicide? How did the perpetrator leave the locked compartment?
3. Investigate the Tunnel: Go to the tunnel indicated by the map. You'll find evidence of someone having been outside the train, near the tunnel entrance, at the time of the incident.
4. Return to the Train Compartment: Re-examine the hole in the window. Use a test to determine the angle of the shot and the trajectory. This will confirm if the shot could have been fired from outside the train.

IV. Interrogation and Accusation

1. Identify Potential Suspects: Based on your deductions, you'll have one primary suspect.
2. Interrogate the Suspect: Present your evidence and deductions. Pay close attention to their reactions and any inconsistencies in their story.

V. Moral Choice

1. Make Your Accusation: Based on your deductions, accuse the person you believe is responsible.
2. Choose to Condemn or Absolve: Consider all the evidence and make your final judgment.

Key Clues and Deductions:

• The locked compartment suggests suicide or a carefully planned murder.
• The riddle is the key to finding the map and the location near the tunnel.
• The hole in the window and the angle of the shot are crucial for determining if the shot was fired from inside or outside the train.
• The evidence at the tunnel confirms someone was outside the train during the time of the incident.

By carefully examining the crime scene, deciphering the riddle, and using your deduction skills, you can solve the mystery of the "Riddle on the Rails" and make a morally challenging decision. Remember, there can be multiple valid deductions and moral choices, leading to different outcomes.

Case 3: Blood Bath

This walkthrough will guide you through the third case in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, "Blood Bath," which involves a series of ritualistic murders in Whitechapel.

I. The First Crime Scene – Mitre Square

1. Arrive at the Scene: You and Watson arrive at Mitre Square, the site of the first murder.
2. Examine the Body:
   • Note the ritualistic placement of the body and the symbols drawn in blood.
   • Observe the specific wounds and the removal of certain organs.
3. Examine the Scene:
   • Look for any footprints or other signs of the perpetrator.
   • Note the chalk markings on the walls.
4. Use Sherlock’s Senses:
   • Reconstruct the events leading up to the murder.
   • Focus on the smell of blood and the eerie atmosphere.

II. Gathering Evidence and Research

1. Consult the Medical Expert: Visit a medical expert to learn more about the specific wounds and the removal of the organs. This will provide crucial insight into the killer’s methods and possible motives.
2. Research Occult Practices: Research books and articles on occult rituals and symbolism. This will help you understand the meaning of the symbols found at the crime scene. The key is to find information about Thuggee rituals.
3. Visit the Second Crime Scene: Another body is found with similar markings. Examine this scene as you did the first, noting any similarities or differences.
4. Examine the Chalk Markings: Analyze the chalk markings found at both crime scenes. They are connected to the Thuggee cult.
5. Interview Witnesses: Talk to residents and witnesses in the area. Gather any information they might have about suspicious activity or individuals.

III. The Importance of the Thuggee Cult

1. Focus on the Thuggee Connection: Your research will reveal the connection to the Thuggee, an Indian cult known for ritualistic killings. This is a vital lead.
2. Examine the Victims' Backgrounds: Look for any possible connections between the victims and the Thuggee cult. This could be anything related to India, the East India Company, or similar links.

IV. Deduction and Interrogation

1. Use the Deduction Board: Connect the evidence: the ritualistic killings, the symbols, the organ removal, the chalk markings, and the Thuggee connection.
2. Develop Theories: Consider several possible scenarios. Is the killer a member of the Thuggee cult? Is he imitating their rituals? Is there a personal connection between the victims and the cult?
3. Identify Potential Suspects: Based on your deductions and the information you've gathered, you'll identify several potential suspects.
4. Interrogate the Suspects: Use your observation skills to detect lies and inconsistencies. Present your evidence and deductions to each suspect.

V. The Importance of the Kukri Knife

1. Locate a Kukri Knife: A Kukri knife, a distinctive curved knife associated with Nepal and the Thuggee, becomes a crucial piece of evidence. You'll need to find one to examine.
2. Examine the Knife: Compare the wounds on the victims with the characteristics of a Kukri knife. This will help you confirm the murder weapon.

VI. Moral Choice

1. Make Your Accusation: Based on your deductions, accuse the person you believe is responsible.
2. Choose to Condemn or Absolve: Consider all the evidence and make your final judgment. This case has particularly complex moral implications.

Key Clues and Deductions:

• The ritualistic nature of the killings and the specific wounds point to a ritualistic motive.
• The symbols and chalk markings are linked to the Thuggee cult.
• Researching the Thuggee is essential for understanding the killer’s methods and possible motives.
• The Kukri knife becomes a crucial piece of physical evidence.
• Finding a connection between the victims and the Thuggee is vital.

This case is heavy on research and deduction. By carefully examining the crime scenes, researching occult practices and the Thuggee cult, and using your deduction skills, you can solve the mystery of the "Blood Bath" murders and make a morally complex decision. Remember, there can be multiple valid deductions and moral choices, leading to different outcomes.

Case 4: The Abbey Grange Affair

This walkthrough covers the fourth case in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, "The Abbey Grange Affair," involving the death of Sir Eustace Brackenstall.

I. The Crime Scene – Abbey Grange

1. Arrive at Abbey Grange: You and Watson arrive at the manor house where Sir Eustace Brackenstall has been murdered.
2. Examine the Body:
   • Note the injuries and the position of the body.
   • Observe the iron bar lying nearby.
3. Examine the Scene:
   • Look for signs of forced entry, specifically at the French windows.
   • Examine the broken decanter and scattered objects, suggesting a struggle.
   • Note the presence of two wine glasses.
   • Pay attention to the safe and whether it has been tampered with.
4. Use Sherlock’s Senses:
   • Reconstruct the events leading up to the murder.
   • Focus on the signs of a violent struggle and the apparent robbery.

II. Gathering Evidence and Interviewing Witnesses

1. Interview Lady Brackenstall: Question her about the events of the night, her relationship with her husband, and any potential suspects.
2. Interview the Housekeeper (Theresa Wright): Gather her account of the events and any observations she made.
3. Interview the Constable: Learn about the initial findings of the police investigation.
4. Examine the French Windows Closely: Focus on the method of entry. You'll find evidence that the break-in was staged.
5. Examine the Iron Bar: Analyze the bar used as the murder weapon. You'll find it doesn't quite match the wounds.
6. Examine the Wine Glasses: One glass has lipstick on it, suggesting a female guest.

III. The Importance of the Brooch and the Sailor

1. Find the Missing Brooch: Lady Brackenstall mentions a missing brooch. Search the grounds and surrounding area. You will find it hidden outside. This is a crucial piece of evidence.
2. Learn about the Sailor: Lady Brackenstall mentions a sailor she saw earlier that day. This becomes a key lead.

IV. Deduction and Interrogation

1. Use the Deduction Board: Connect the evidence: the staged break-in, the mismatched wounds and iron bar, the two wine glasses, the missing brooch, and the sailor.
2. Develop Theories: Consider different scenarios. Was it a simple robbery gone wrong? Was it a planned murder? What role did the sailor play?
3. Investigate the Sailor's Background: Follow the leads to find out more about the sailor. You'll discover his connection to Lady Brackenstall.
4. Confront Lady Brackenstall: Re-interview Lady Brackenstall with your new evidence. Her story will likely change.
5. Consider the Timeline: Reconstruct the timeline of events based on the testimonies and evidence. This will reveal inconsistencies in the initial accounts.

V. The Importance of the Letter

1. Find the Letter: A hidden letter will be found, revealing the true nature of Lady Brackenstall's relationship with the sailor. This is a critical piece of evidence.

VI. Moral Choice

1. Make Your Accusation: Based on your deductions, accuse the person you believe is responsible. There are multiple valid deductions and therefore possible accused parties.
2. Choose to Condemn or Absolve: This case presents a complex moral dilemma. You must consider the circumstances surrounding the murder and the motivations of the individuals involved. The law versus moral justice plays a big role here.

Key Clues and Deductions:

• The staged break-in suggests the crime scene was tampered with.
• The mismatched wounds and iron bar indicate the murder weapon might not be the one found at the scene.
• The missing brooch and the sailor are crucial leads.
• The letter reveals the true relationship between Lady Brackenstall and the sailor.
• The timeline of events exposes inconsistencies in the initial testimonies.

This case focuses on observation, deduction, and understanding human relationships. By carefully examining the crime scene, gathering evidence, and analyzing the testimonies, you can solve the mystery of "The Abbey Grange Affair" and make a morally challenging decision. Remember, there are multiple valid deductions and moral choices, leading to different outcomes.

Case 5: The Kew Gardens Drama

This walkthrough covers the fifth case in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, "The Kew Gardens Drama," which involves the death of the director of Kew Gardens.

I. The Crime Scene – Kew Gardens

1. Arrive at Kew Gardens: You and Watson arrive at the scene of the crime.
2. Examine the Body:
   • Note the cause of death (poisoning).
   • Observe the discoloration of the skin.
3. Examine the Scene:
   • Focus on the immediate area around the body.
   • Look for any signs of a struggle or disturbance.
   • Note the presence of rare plants and the specific greenhouse where the body was found.
4. Use Sherlock’s Senses:
   • Reconstruct the events leading up to the death.
   • Pay attention to the various scents of plants and the controlled environment of the greenhouse.

II. Gathering Evidence and Interviewing Witnesses

1. Interview the Botanists/Staff: Question the staff at Kew Gardens about the victim, his work, any recent events, and any potential suspects. Pay close attention to their knowledge of plants and poisons.
2. Examine the Greenhouse: Carefully inspect the plants in the greenhouse, especially those near the body. Look for any signs of tampering or damage.
3. Examine the Victim's Office: Search his office for any clues, such as notes, letters, or research papers.
4. Research Poisonous Plants: Consult books and experts on poisonous plants to identify the specific poison used. The Gloriosa superba (Flame Lily) is the key plant here.
5. Examine the Tea Set: A tea set is found in the office. Examine it for traces of poison.

III. The Importance of the Rare Orchid and the Rivalry

1. Focus on the Missing Orchid: Learn about a rare and valuable orchid that was recently stolen from Kew Gardens. This becomes a central part of the investigation.
2. Investigate the Rivalry: Discover a professional rivalry between the victim and another botanist. This rivalry provides a potential motive.

IV. Deduction and Interrogation

1. Use the Deduction Board: Connect the evidence: the poisoning, the rare plants, the missing orchid, the professional rivalry, and the tea set.
2. Develop Theories: Consider several possible scenarios. Was it a planned murder? Was it an accident involving poisonous plants? Was the theft of the orchid connected to the murder?
3. Identify Potential Suspects: Based on your deductions and the information you've gathered, you'll identify several potential suspects, including the rival botanist and potentially others within Kew Gardens.
4. Interrogate the Suspects: Use your observation skills to detect lies and inconsistencies. Present your evidence and deductions to each suspect.

V. The Importance of the Greenhouse Key and the Footprints

1. Find the Greenhouse Key: The key to the greenhouse where the victim was found becomes an important piece of evidence. Determine who had access to it.
2. Examine the Footprints: Look for footprints inside and outside the greenhouse. This can provide clues about the movements of the perpetrator.

VI. The Importance of the Notebook

1. Find a notebook that details the victim's research and experiments. This can provide valuable information about his work with poisonous plants and potentially reveal a motive or clue.

VII. Moral Choice

1. Make Your Accusation: Based on your deductions, accuse the person you believe is responsible.
2. Choose to Condemn or Absolve: Consider all the evidence and make your final judgment.

Key Clues and Deductions:

• The poisoning and the specific symptoms point to a particular type of poison.
• The missing orchid and the professional rivalry provide potential motives.
• The tea set, the greenhouse key, and the footprints are important pieces of physical evidence.
• The victim's research and experiments can reveal valuable clues.

This case emphasizes observation, scientific deduction, and understanding the world of botany. By carefully examining the crime scene, researching poisonous plants, and analyzing the testimonies, you can solve the mystery of "The Kew Gardens Drama" and make a morally challenging decision. Remember, there are multiple valid deductions and moral choices, leading to different outcomes.

Case 6: A Half Moon Walk

This walkthrough covers the sixth and final case in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, "A Half Moon Walk," where Wiggins, one of Holmes' Baker Street Irregulars, is implicated in a murder. This case is more personal and emotionally charged for Holmes.

I. The Crime Scene – The Docks/Warehouse

1. Arrive at the Docks/Warehouse: You and Watson arrive at the scene of the crime.
2. Examine the Body:
   • Note the cause of death.
   • Observe the surroundings and the position of the body.
3. Examine the Scene:
   • Focus on the immediate area around the body.
   • Look for any signs of a struggle or disturbance.
   • Note any specific details about the warehouse and its contents.
4. Use Sherlock’s Senses:
   • Reconstruct the events leading up to the death.
   • Pay attention to the sounds and smells of the docks.

II. Gathering Evidence and Interviewing Witnesses

1. Interview the Witnesses: Talk to any witnesses present at the scene or in the surrounding area. Gather information about what they saw and heard.
2. Examine the Area for Clues: Search the area for any physical evidence, such as footprints, objects left behind, or signs of a struggle.
3. Find Wiggins: Locate Wiggins, who is hiding and distressed. Talk to him to get his version of events. He will be reluctant to talk at first.
4. Examine Wiggins's Belongings/Person: Carefully examine Wiggins's clothing and belongings for any evidence that might connect him to the crime.
5. Visit the Victim's Residence: Investigate the victim’s home for any clues about their life, relationships, and potential enemies.

III. The Importance of the Missing Money and the Gambling Debt

1. Investigate the Missing Money: Discover that a significant amount of money is missing from the victim. This establishes a clear motive for robbery.
2. Learn about the Gambling Debt: Find evidence that Wiggins had a gambling debt and was in desperate need of money. This creates a strong suspicion against him.

IV. Deduction and Interrogation

1. Use the Deduction Board: Connect the evidence: the murder, the missing money, Wiggins's gambling debt, his presence at the scene, and any other clues you find.
2. Consider Different Scenarios: Explore different possibilities. Did Wiggins commit the murder? Was he framed? Was he involved in some other way?
3. Reconstruct the Timeline: Recreate the sequence of events leading up to the murder based on the testimonies and evidence.
4. Examine the victim's social circle: Look for any connections, rivalries, or other reasons someone might want the victim dead.

V. The Importance of the Other Suspects and Their Motives

1. Identify Other Suspects: As you investigate, you'll uncover other individuals who had connections to the victim and potential motives for the murder.
2. Investigate Their Motives: Explore the motives of these other suspects. This will provide alternative explanations for the murder and potentially exonerate Wiggins.

VI. The Importance of the Specific Knife/Weapon

1. Determine the exact type of weapon used in the murder. This can be a crucial piece of evidence in connecting or disconnecting Wiggins from the crime.

VII. Moral Choice – The Personal Dilemma

1. Make Your Accusation: Based on your deductions, accuse the person you believe is responsible.
2. Choose to Condemn or Absolve Wiggins: This is the core of the case. Even if the evidence strongly suggests Wiggins's guilt, you must consider the circumstances, his character, and the possibility of him being framed. This is a very personal and difficult decision for Holmes.

Key Clues and Deductions:

• The missing money and Wiggins's gambling debt create strong suspicion.
• The testimonies of witnesses and Wiggins's own account are crucial.
• Identifying other suspects and their motives is essential for a complete investigation.
• The type of weapon used is a key piece of forensic evidence.
• The moral choice regarding Wiggins is the central dilemma of the case.

This case is unique because of its personal nature. It's not just about solving a crime; it's about Holmes facing a moral conflict involving someone he cares about. By carefully examining the evidence, exploring all possibilities, and making a difficult moral choice, you'll conclude this final case and the game. Remember, there are multiple valid deductions and moral choices, leading to different outcomes.